Learned Ignorance

Mother, forgive us for we do what we do not know. - learned ignorance

Saturday, September 27, 2025

"Notes of a Gentle Cynic" when Darkness around us is Deep.

 A complement to this public journal, Notes of a Gentle Cynic, which survives after more than fourteen years having adopted a structure that captures a kind and quality of artful living that encompasses serious notions in a pursuit and advancement of an art of life, which has its roots in ancient thought and wisdom with a conceived relevance in a time that may well be a “moral dark ages”[1].

“Gentle Cynicism” maintains moral and cognitive way of moving through--not stepping away from—tensions where there is a complex array of easy-to-get thin practices, answers and ideals on one side, while beyond—profound, thick resources that invite persistent minds toward the way of becoming more fully human. The task is one of becoming comfortable with doubt, negation and integration via patient dialectical knowing and learned ignorance offering dynamic forms conceived over time into honed praxis, livelihood and embodied wisdom overcoming combinatorial explosion[2].


[1] Alasdair MacIntyre, After Virtue, used this comparison suggesting that modern society faces challenges similar to the post-Roman Empire period. He posits that just as the legacy of classical civilization was preserved in monasteries during that time, it is necessary to create "local forms of community within which . . . the intellectual and moral life can be sustained through the new dark ages". Some suggest that the barbarians, in this context, are not outside the system, but have already been governing.  

[2] By way of recursive relevance realization avoiding combinatorial explosion, ill-definedness, and the way in which we can be misdirected by salience to misjudge what is relevant in any given problem. See John Vervaeke, Leonardo Ferraro, “Relevance, Meaning and the Cognitive Science of Wisdom” in The Scientific Study of Personal Wisdom, Nov 2013, 21-51.  https://www.researchgate.net/publication/286508333_Relevance_Meaning_and_the_Cognitive_Science_of_Wisdom

 



Sunday, September 21, 2025

Resident Alien Rooted in and Enlightened by Axial Aged Logos

 As I am becoming, I am recognizing a relevant tension living in empire: the therapeutic defined within the parameters of a dominant scripting embellished to provide services while largely and complicitly promoting the same failing script of “therapeutic, technological, consumerist militarism” (ttcm) that permeates every dimension of our common life.”[1] Thus, it keeps an illusion of safety and happiness before the masses with its  network of advertisement (used broadly), a huge culprit of collective discouragement, exploitation, numbness and is more often absent of critical reflection on the existential level.

There is no easy way out of this gravitational pull of empire’s script of ttcm. John Vervaeke describes the totality of a present collective tumult as a “meaning crisis”.[2] Understanding the meaning crisis begins by realizing the script or story you tell yourself and live by.

Everybody lives by a script—whether implicit or explicit.  We get scripted through the process of nurture, formation and socialization, and it happens without our knowing it.  The dominant script in our society is one of technological therapeutic military consumerism.  It is a script enacted through advertising, propaganda and ideology, especially in the liturgies of television, promises to keep us safe and happy. That script has failed. The script of technological therapeutic military consumerism cannot make us safe or happy. It’s a story we choose when we have no story.

Resident Aliens echoes Jesus of Nazareth calling for radical awakening to empire: to nudge some beyond the whelm of noise and plague of memes generating artificial sense of safety, fears, and collective anxiety that are felt locally unto globally due to empire.

*

PAUSE in time allowing opportunity to take flight, suspend raw chance (hap[3]) and remain self-making (poiesis).

Wendall Berry, one in ten thousand, a truth-teller, wrote awoke of moments in the cosmos,

Blessing and blessed in this result

Of times not blessed, now he has seen.

He walks in quiet beyond division

In surcease of his own tumult

1984, V

 

Why must the gate be narrow?

Because you cannot pass beyond it burdened.

To come in among these trees you must leave behind

The six days’ world, all of it, all of its plans and hopes.

You must come without weapon or tool, alone,

expecting nothing, remembering nothing

into the ease of sight, the brotherhood of eye and leaf.

1985, V[4]

 I carry a new unburdening and fortuate existence of one mourning, with the possibility of being summoned, called a witness, invited and even encouraged to partake (poiesis) in a realm, hence body where quiet reigns in attention and peacefully with pity;  persevere in small things allying the tumult from within while “times not blessed” surround me.

*

Resident Alian is a call to church (being called out of) much like the early chapters of Apocalypse of John, where there is enough rebuke to go around for all of us who have and may still consider themselves born into the Christian church[5], for this is our mother-tongue[6] and now perhaps forms a flexible, free space or niche where we work at looking curiously into oneness that is genuine liberation rooted in a narrative structure ,a story remembered, which lives on ana-theistically in one’s own mind and adventure.

Breaking free of the dominant story (ttcm), working out one’s own meaning crisis takes on a form of imaginal work (wonder, awe)—creative work (poesis) that may follow a Beatitudinal pathway or dark night of the soul [Rubedo[7]) viewing oneself in a narrative structure: a story, a part played in that story, orienting oneself with learned pathways along a Way till hope is being realized, always caring deeply of one’s self;  taking into account what Thích Nhất Hạnh remined us that it is this kind and quality of inner work emerging from a ground within; for “The way out is in.”

From this narrative structure realized necessitates a narrowing, purging via Rubedo. Ennobled via the axial-aged tradition, Buddhism, is the symbol dukka in “life is suffering” (first noble provocation). It means to undergo loss of agency (not pain) being fettered by a threat of losing one’s freedom/agency, like a misaligned wheel that’s’ weakening, ready to dismember unless we yield to a repair/change, mending a limb out of joint, or the mind from self-deception and potential ruin living among violence. A saying of Jesus of Nazareth when asked about a recent scene of destruction or violence reported nearby, said, “Unless you have a radical change of mind (metanoia) you too will come to ruin/destruction. 

These sources of wisdom emerge from rooted stories and their logos (study, word about) with their ennobling provocations. If they are heard, seen beyond myopic belief, i.e. beyond the propositional and anemic procedural (e.g., the liturgies of American evangelicalism encumbered in southern racism, America’s original sin[8], laced with fundamentalism[9]); they have potential to affect the ground within profusely over time infusing vitality, reviving perspectival knowing leveling us through transformation—liberation.

From a narrative structure we discover a nomological structure, a procedure (set of rules and laws), e.g., natural law behind all things (vs. mechanism, procedural without perspectival knowing). This is where practice and memory work come in. One takes on e.g. the eight-fold noble path, a Beatitudinal transcendence (ideal for living/occupied by empire)[10]; something that makes sense overtime providing an intelligibility resulting in coherence [vs the duplicity felt living among ttcm], an evolutionary backdrop that opens up other disciplines and study contained in infinite conversations. Vervaeke sees this kind of dynamic working with computer gaming devotees; for there is a sense of coherence with rules and laws that provide a sense of order in chaos as well as a normative structure which drives transcendence, that is, one can level up—transcendence is available, and thus one gains “significance, a normative staircase that gets you in touch with the really real.”

There’s a generating of Imaginal wonder that takes on  “courage to be” (Tillich, 1952)—flight at a level where speech [language of logos] in whatever valid form presented provides enough coherence to move up a level in art of dialecticart of life . . . Something matters!

This mattering leads to feeling connected to something that has a reality and value beyond one’s own individual existence, where “love and need are one, and the work is play for mortal stakes” (R. Frost). The autotelic personality takes on greater investment of practice via a quality of experiences that function in relationship between levels of challenges and skills, an expansion of optimal performance or Flow states (M. Csikszentmihalyi 1991, 1917). Hence, what is mattering translates into one’s livelihood and effort bringing out what is uniquely yours to work out, a cultivation of knowledge, skill and attitude that enjoys what one is doing regardless of whether one gets external rewards from it—the work is/has its own reward.

It is no easy path traversing from being externally driven toward a cessation of attachments such as comfort, money, material things, power or fame, and illusory concepts of success dictated by a dominant script, which one chose when one had no story, to  being dynamically coupled, connected with an alternative environment, knowing where to cultivate wisdom, to ameliorate self-deception, escape destructiveness and shun foolishness, and eventually enhance connectiveness (religio) and living what the great axial traditions[11] left for us as sources of wisdom and having ongoing access to the narrow WAY, logos, and my favorite, a resurrection of death—"to live as if you are already dead”.

 Within this perspective then, the question for everyone is:

where one will stand, for what one will do.[12]



[1] “Walter Brueggemann’s 19 Theses” 2004 Emergent Theological Conversation with Walter Brueggemann. Can be read at https://www.patheos.com/blogs/paperbacktheology/2014/04/walter-brueggemanns-19-thesis-revisited-a-clarification-from-brueggemann-himself.html  A recommended starting point in beginning to unwrap the death napkin over one’s eyes to a bright light leading to in the truest manner—enlightenment now if it’s not too late.

[2] John Vervaeke Awakening from the Meaning Crisis with lessons by John Vervaeke, can be found on YouTube (50-hour lecture series)—highly recommended.

[4] Wendell Berry, This Day: Sabbath Poems Collected & New, 1979-2013. Berkeley: Counterpoint, 2013.

[5] “Church”, the sense of how Hauerwas and Willimon use the term, it is specific to the Protestant church broadly speaking in the US, yet offers clarity in responding to implications of empire as a “called-out” community to work out a life of meaning within the tradition of Christ [logos] with a critical gaze at pre-Christendom much like a good philosopher studies Socrates from later sources [He too was killed for his manner of living and offering a similar quality salvific advantage].

One must reach back to its roots to find again the path forward of its logos, its reach is to a depth of joint and morrow of the soul that summons to each their own adventure with the sacred. I posit meaning out of one who is a seeker, a follower—one who seeks the way each day and loses attachments to names, beliefs, dogmas, persons until one is alone, dead—non-being, being stripped from the way of world’s script taking on emerging new view, understanding, language, leading to a desire for actionable, practical means and ways evoked out of a profound need—even poverty—to care for oneself as primacy to being in harmony with those outside—I am being called out!

[6] I allude to one’s “route of inheritance” which may include a strong sense of archetypal images active in one’s imaginal wonderings—adventures.

[7] Reddening in alchemy; within Jung’s parlance, a spirit that was freed in the previous stage needs to be united with psyche again. Spirit that has been awakened now needs to be expressed fittingly and authentically in life/work. This is the stage of adjustment and re-alignment with indorsed goals/pathways with its virtues and practices in its narrowing, unique of purpose [8FNP absorption] that includes sublimatio, mortificatio and ultimately coniunctio.

[10] Referring to the compilation of sayings of Jesus of Nazareth contained in the literary genre of ancient Greek gospel (proclamation of good news, commonly used by political leaders, which underscores the political counter script of Jesus movement at a critical and  tumultuous period occupied by empire), specifically, The Sermon on the Mount (framed to echo Moses on the Mt Sinai—that profound liberation from empire in Hebraic history). The view I encourage is reading the Sermon on the Mount as illuminating an inward spiritual kingdom [body] with cognitive, practical, ethical, moral implications. It was meant for a short time, as its content concerned issues [living under empire, civil unrest, evil and good are confused, etc.] that may not be relevant for a world that continues century upon century; yet again this kind and quality of emergence may call on us during tumultuous times.

[11] Karl jaspers, The Origin and Goal of History, Yake Univ. Press, 1952, 2

The most extraordinary events are concentrated in this period, Confucius and Lao-tse were living in China, all the schools of Chinese philosophy came into being, including those of Mo-ti, Chuang-tse, Lieh-tsu and a host of others; India produced the Upanishads and Buddha and, like China, ran the whole gamut of philosophical possibilities down to skepticism, to materialism, sophism and nihilism; in Iran Zarathustra taught a challenging view of the world as a struggle between good and evil; in Palestine the prophets made their appearance, from Elijah^ by way of Isaiah and Jeremiah to Deutero-Isaiah; Greece witnessed the appearance of Homer, of the philosophers Parmenides, Heraclitus and Plato of the tragedians, Thucydides and Archimedes. Everything implied by these names developed during these few centuries almost simultaneously in China, India, and the West, without any one of these regions knowing of the others.

[12] Jaspers, 276